Landlord and tenant: brewery tie
Landlord and tenant: brewery tie
- 2002
- Estates Gazette Case Summaries [2002] 06 EG 154 (CS) (9/02/02) .
CA 31 January 2002. "Plummer v TIBSCO Ltd". Respondent P was the tenant of a public house under a five-year lease that contained tie provisions. Clause 26 of the lease gave P the option to renew the lease if tie provisions were fulfilled. Later P and the appellant landlord T agreed the tie provisions had become unlawful. P exercised the option to renew the lease. T refused renewal on the grounds that the tie provisions had not been fulfilled. P agreed to take a lease on different terms and subsequently brought a successful claim for damages for breach of contract. T appealed. Appeal allowed: by accepting the 20-year term P compromised his claim to a five-year lease and his claim for damages for breach of contract.
PUBLIC HOUSES
TIE PROVISIONS
PLUMMER V TIBSCO LTD
SUPPLY OF BEER (TIED ESTATE) ORDER 1989
LEASE RENEWAL
CA 31 January 2002. "Plummer v TIBSCO Ltd". Respondent P was the tenant of a public house under a five-year lease that contained tie provisions. Clause 26 of the lease gave P the option to renew the lease if tie provisions were fulfilled. Later P and the appellant landlord T agreed the tie provisions had become unlawful. P exercised the option to renew the lease. T refused renewal on the grounds that the tie provisions had not been fulfilled. P agreed to take a lease on different terms and subsequently brought a successful claim for damages for breach of contract. T appealed. Appeal allowed: by accepting the 20-year term P compromised his claim to a five-year lease and his claim for damages for breach of contract.
PUBLIC HOUSES
TIE PROVISIONS
PLUMMER V TIBSCO LTD
SUPPLY OF BEER (TIED ESTATE) ORDER 1989
LEASE RENEWAL