Gilje and others v Charlgrove Securities Ltd
Gilje and others v Charlgrove Securities Ltd
- 2002
- Estates Gazette [2002] 16 EG 182-185(4) .
CA 4 October 2001. Appellant landlord (C) owned headlease of building containing four flats let to respondent tenants (G). Included covenant by C to provide resident housekeeper, and C sought to recover notional rent for flat in service charge. Then C increased caretakers wage, but deducted sum equal to increase, as rent for flat, and sought to recover from G full amount of caretakers increased wages. G challenged liability to pay various items in service charge in application to leasehold valuation tribunal. Which decided that amount charged and increased wages were reasonable. G challenged the LVT and LT's decisions in the CC who found in favour of G. The CA dismissed C's appeals. CC decisions upheld.
GILJE AND OTHERS V CHARLEGROVE SECURITIES LTD AND ANOTHER
NOTIONAL RENT
LANDLORD AND TENANT ACT 1985
AGAVIL INVESTMENT CO V CORNER
CA 4 October 2001. Appellant landlord (C) owned headlease of building containing four flats let to respondent tenants (G). Included covenant by C to provide resident housekeeper, and C sought to recover notional rent for flat in service charge. Then C increased caretakers wage, but deducted sum equal to increase, as rent for flat, and sought to recover from G full amount of caretakers increased wages. G challenged liability to pay various items in service charge in application to leasehold valuation tribunal. Which decided that amount charged and increased wages were reasonable. G challenged the LVT and LT's decisions in the CC who found in favour of G. The CA dismissed C's appeals. CC decisions upheld.
GILJE AND OTHERS V CHARLEGROVE SECURITIES LTD AND ANOTHER
NOTIONAL RENT
LANDLORD AND TENANT ACT 1985
AGAVIL INVESTMENT CO V CORNER