It's a matter of opinion
It's a matter of opinion
- 2003
- Estates Gazette (0336) 6 September 2003, 109(1) .
Examines the outcomes of two cases "Marazzi v Global Grange Ltd" and "Ivory Grove Ltd v Global Grange Ltd" which had similar facts but different outcomes. In both cases broadly similar works were to be carried out on properties. The trial judges came to different conclusions as to whether the respective works satisfied Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 s30(1)(f). Argues that the two cases should have been tried together but in the absence of any legal flaws in the trial judges' reasoning there was no basis for any interference on either appeal.
MARAZZI AND ANOTHER V GLOBAL GRANGE LTD
IVORY GROVE LTD V GLOBAL GRANGE LTD
LANDLORD AND TENANT ACT 1954 S30(1)(F)
STRUCTURAL WORKS
HOTELS
DEMOLITION
BUILT ENVIRONMENT-BUILDING MAINTENANCE AND REFURBISHMENT
Examines the outcomes of two cases "Marazzi v Global Grange Ltd" and "Ivory Grove Ltd v Global Grange Ltd" which had similar facts but different outcomes. In both cases broadly similar works were to be carried out on properties. The trial judges came to different conclusions as to whether the respective works satisfied Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 s30(1)(f). Argues that the two cases should have been tried together but in the absence of any legal flaws in the trial judges' reasoning there was no basis for any interference on either appeal.
MARAZZI AND ANOTHER V GLOBAL GRANGE LTD
IVORY GROVE LTD V GLOBAL GRANGE LTD
LANDLORD AND TENANT ACT 1954 S30(1)(F)
STRUCTURAL WORKS
HOTELS
DEMOLITION
BUILT ENVIRONMENT-BUILDING MAINTENANCE AND REFURBISHMENT