Image from Google Jackets

Ghaidan v Godin-Mendoza

Series: Weekly Law Reports ; [2004] 3 WLR 113-160(48)Publication details: 2004Subject(s): Summary: [2004] UKHL 30, 21 June 2004. Appeal by landlord (G) against CA's decision ([2001] EWCA Civ 1553, Abs66275) that tenant (G-M) was entitled to succeed to the tenancy of a flat as a statutory tenant under the Rent Act 1977 Sched 1 para 2. G-M had been living in the flat in a stable same-sex relationship with the original tenant until the latter's death in January 2001. CA overturned the lower court's decision that G-M could not succeed to the tenancy of the flat as the surviving spouse of the original tenant within the meaning of the 1977 Act Sched 1 para 2 as that provision excluded persons in a same-sex relationship. "Held": A survivor of a same-sex couple cannot not become a statutory tenant by succession within para 2(2) of the 1977 Act following "Fitzpatrick v Sterling House Association Ltd" (HL, Abs61717) a decision made before the Human Rights Act 1988 came into force. The difference in treatment on grounds of sexual orientation flowing from the "Fitzpatrick " interpretation infringed the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms Arts 8 and 14. The court made para 2 compliant with Convention rights by reading it as covering same-sex couples living together and therefore the survivor of such a couple should be treated as the surviving spouse of the original tenant. Judgment is available at www.parliament.uk.
Holdings
Item type Current library Call number Copy number Status Barcode
Law report London Journal article ABS67950 (Browse shelf(Opens below)) 1 Available 126613-1001

[2004] UKHL 30, 21 June 2004. Appeal by landlord (G) against CA's decision ([2001] EWCA Civ 1553, Abs66275) that tenant (G-M) was entitled to succeed to the tenancy of a flat as a statutory tenant under the Rent Act 1977 Sched 1 para 2. G-M had been living in the flat in a stable same-sex relationship with the original tenant until the latter's death in January 2001. CA overturned the lower court's decision that G-M could not succeed to the tenancy of the flat as the surviving spouse of the original tenant within the meaning of the 1977 Act Sched 1 para 2 as that provision excluded persons in a same-sex relationship. "Held": A survivor of a same-sex couple cannot not become a statutory tenant by succession within para 2(2) of the 1977 Act following "Fitzpatrick v Sterling House Association Ltd" (HL, Abs61717) a decision made before the Human Rights Act 1988 came into force. The difference in treatment on grounds of sexual orientation flowing from the "Fitzpatrick " interpretation infringed the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms Arts 8 and 14. The court made para 2 compliant with Convention rights by reading it as covering same-sex couples living together and therefore the survivor of such a couple should be treated as the surviving spouse of the original tenant. Judgment is available at www.parliament.uk.