000			01753naa a22001937a 4500
007			c| aa aaaaanaa
008			241114e20241108xxk||||os||||o00| 0 eng d
041			_aeng
110			_aRoyal Courts of Justice _94330
245			_aCoastal Housing Group Limited v Mitchell and Ors
260			_a[2024] EWHC 2831 (Ch) _bChancery Division _c8 November 2024
520			_aA test case before Mr Justice Griffiths and Judge Jarman KC under the Renting Homes (Wales) Act 2016, the High Court held that contract-holders (known as tenants before the RHW Act) under converted occupation contracts were not liable to pay rent until their landlords had provided them with electrical condition reports; until then, the dwellings were treated as being unfit for human habitation. In each of the test cases, the claimant landlords commissioned an ECR but failed to provide the contract-holders with a copy for several months. Various details such as whether contract-holders had the right to claim back paid rent (none had in fact withheld rent) was not a matter explored by this case. Looked at the landlords claim there was a distinction between “actual” breach (where as a matter of fact the dwelling is unfit for human habitation because of some electrical fault) and “deemed” breach (where the property is fit for human habitation because there are no electrical faults but the administrative failure to provide the certificate means the dwelling is “deemed” to be unfit).
650			_aRENTING HOMES (WALES) ACT 2016
650			_aLANDLORD AND TENANT
650			_aELECTRICAL CONDITION REPORTS
650			_aUNFIT HOMES
651			_aWales
856			_uhttps://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/ch/2024/2831 _zAvailable from caselaw archive
999			_c122057 _d122057