000 01937cad a22002295a 4500
001 L144935
008 080826e20080314xxk f v 000 0 eng d
035 _a(Sirsi) u144935
041 0 _aeng
245 0 0 _aJS Bloor Ltd v Pavillion Developments Ltd
_h[electronic resource]
260 _c2008
520 _a[2008] EWHC 724 (TCC), 14 March 2008. Despite a variety of unknown quantities, a developer could not claim expenses from an individual whose land it had accidentally improved. Claimant (B), a property developer, sold land to other developers including respondent (P). An agreement existed whereby B would build and maintain an access road and P would build another access road at a later date. B ended up mistakenly building both roads and tried to claim for the expense of the incontrovertible benefits that they claim were afforded to P as a result of this error. P maintained that English law does not hold a developer responsible for mistaken improvements by another party to their land. Case dismissed: B could not reclaim costs from P as it enjoyed non-pecuniary improvements to access and other benefits as a result of creating the road. The judge also found that P had suffered disadvantages as a result of the road creation, including the inability to choose the specification for the section of road that they had agreed to build. An additional charge laid by B that P had dumped spoil on its land was also rejected by the judge, as there was evidence to the contrary.
590 _aKA
650 2 4 _aJS BLOOR LTD V PAVILLION DEVELOPMENTS LTD
650 2 4 _aBLUE HAVEN ENTERPRISES LTD V TULLY
650 2 4 _aTAYLOR FASHIONS LTD V LIVERPOOL VICTORIA TRUSTEES CO LTD
650 2 4 _aWILMOTT V BARBER
651 4 _aEngland and Wales
_y1543-
690 _aPROPERTY AND LAND LAW
856 4 0 _uhttps://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/TCC/2008/724.html
_zView the case free of charge online at www.bailii.org...
942 _n0
999 _c80652
_d80652